Archive for the 'Frequently Asked' Category
Wednesday, August 18th, 2010
QUESTION: Hi,
Is there a trick to reshafting Honma drivers? The new shaft is Graphite Design
Gtech with a 350 diameter. It goes into the hosel easily enough but only one
inch. It should go at least another half inch to be secure, shouldn’t it. I’m
afraid the shaft will snap if it only goes in 1 inch. I have tried to get
information from Honma with have not had any luck. Thanks, KAO
ANSWER: Hi KAO,
The structural integrity of any installation will determine if a club will stay intact, but equally as important is installing a shaft to the proper hosel depth is to give you the playability that you desire. Factors such as the head weight, bottom of the bore to the ground measurement, overall length desired, and others, will determine how your club will play.
Your main question is- “Will the shaft and head separate if only installed into the head 1″?”. Regarding this, unfortunately, we do not give step by step installation answers, unless it can be definitively determined. Obviously, the more surface contact between shaft tip and hosel, the more secure the bond will be, but also important, is the width of the ahdesive line between the shaft and hosel, the quality of adhesive, the proper abrasion of hosel and shaft, and the cleanliness of shaft and hosel surface.
For both fitting and installation help, you might consider teaming up with one of our Authorized Installation Centers. For this resource, go to www.shaftology.com, click on the CENTER locator link, and contact one or more of our centers and inquire as to the fitting and installation services offered. Â
Partnering up with a professional center will yield a club that remains intact, and plays to the performance level that you desire. Regards, Mark
Posted in Shaft Installation, Frequently Asked |
Monday, August 16th, 2010
QUESTION: Hi,
I have a set of Ping i15 irons with stiff graphite shafts. I came from an i5 Ping steel iron shaft and found them too stiff.
IÂ switched to the graphite, looking for a little more distance, and found them too soft.
I am a 5 handicap, with a smooth swing, age 62, and 6 feet, 210 lbs. I am thinking of trying a Project X or Rifle shaft, 5.0.
Any suggestions? Help! PLB
ANSWER: Hello PLB,
Your best chance of finding equipment that is right for you begins with using some practical common sense.
Leave behind the notions of age, handicap, and body size as criteria for optimal shaft selection.
There are golfers in their 60’s that play like Tom Watson and Hale Irwin, and their are sixty year old golfers who can barely hit the ball a hundred yards. There are 5 handicap players who smash the ball into the heavens, and others who are short hitting, low flight, scrambling 5 handicappers. How could these criteria ever convey any meaning, shaft selection-wise?
Next, jumping from set to set, based on archaic myths of “choose graphite for more power!”, or ”choose what’s popular on tour!”, is a waste of time and will keep you floundering in your current predicament.
Choose your next set based on performance.
The best method, the most accurate equipment method, is to test and compare different models, weight, and flexes, and plug-in your answers to the following performance questions-
“Which model gives the best feel during the swing and at impact?”
“Which model allows my body to swing in the best rhythm, balance, and comfort?”
“Which model allows my swing to achieve the best flight and the most consistent contact?”
“Which model does not force me to make adjustments to achieve the best combination of feel, flight and consistency?”
Our current industry is set up for the ease and speed of selling golf clubs, but this is an anti-gravity system of matching you up with the best performing equipment. It is easy, but often results in a poorly matched set.
Find a source that will help you test different head/shaft models.
One place to start is our Authorized Installation Centers. Go to www.shaftology.com, click on our CENTER locator, and inquire as to the Fitting Services offered.
In your specific case, it sounds like you jumped from a heavy, stiff product to a light, “unstable for your body”, product.
Instead of trying another “maybe” set, I urge you to connect with a Fitting Center that will offer you the experience of testing a sensible variety of head, shaft, and specification combinations so that you can answer the above performance questions.
It make take some time and energy, but it is well worth it.
Please reply with any feedback or questions. Regards, Mark
Posted in Shaft Fitting, Frequently Asked, Golfer Interaction, Ultimate Fitting Destination, General Fitting Questions |
Tuesday, August 3rd, 2010
Note to reader- sorry for the ”run together” style of this note. I have been unable to adjust this particular article. Thanks, MarkÂ
QUESTION: Hi again,I have seen a common thread with your replies: Go hit the shafts and select the one that feels best! Of course, that’s the best approach. But it’s not practical, and it cost you a lot of business. I’m most likely going to go with Project X rather than Nippon, because I’m familiar with Project X and can’t find after 2 weeks of looking, a place to demo the Nippon Steel shafts side be side.
Suggestion: I belong to 2 Country Clubs in California, and I attend about every demo day from club manufacturers. They are all the same- they want to sell you their clubs, regardless of what shaft goes with them. We both know that the shaft has more influence on satisfaction than the club head.
So, you guys should start holding demo days. Pick about 4 different high quality heads, and demo your range of shaft options. Encourage participants to test your shafts against what they currently play. But don’t just go on feel, but measure stats too.
Thanks, Mike
ANSWER: Welcome back Mike,
You bring up several great points, but don’t give up hope on finding your best equipment. I suggest that you jettison the old school mindset of demo days, predictive guess club fitting, and limited shaft testing options, and start exploring the new world.
100 years ago, golf equipment was built one club at a time, with special regard given to testing and fitting the unique needs of the individual golfer. Then, the industrial revolution hit, and prices plummeted and availability soared for off the rack sets, but at the great expense of the individual golfer, who a century later, seeks more than just the off the rack, generic technology, and a return to individually fitted equipment.
With the equipment rulings over the last few years, placing strict technology limits on the major manufacturers, a seismic shift in fitting/testing applications is moving in your direction.
As recent as 5 years ago, there were few testing fitting/testing options for the major head and shaft manufacturers. Because of the technology limits placed on equipment, the major companies are forced to re-direct their resources on fitting and testing options, and you now have 1000’s of locations to test and compare equipment options. It may not be exactly how you want things, but please read on.
Fitting carts from Cobra, Cleveland, Tour Edge, Titleist, Mizuno, Ping, Nike, Taylor Made, Callaway, etc., offer immediate evaluation as to which club feels and flies the best. The next generations systems, including the Callaway Opti-Fit, Taylor Made Select Fit, and Mizuno Optimizer Systems, all offer the opportunity to test and interact with a variety of interchangeable head and shaft options for instant evaluation.
Most every major manufacturer has similar systems in place, or is working on these interchangeable systems for the near future.Â
With the adjustable head systems of Nike, Taylor Made, Callaway, and soon Titleist, and others, the world is fast becoming a testing-friendly world again, as it was 100 years ago.
Even with all of these testing options by the major manufacturers, there is limited opportunities to compare across company lines, which has given rise to several high performance equipment facilities, most notably Hot Stix and Cool Clubs. Both of these firms have several locations around the US and offer the opportunity to interchange and test a variety of head and specialty shaft options. These type firms also blend the feel of the club, the flight of the ball, and the computer data that you seek. There are several other clubmaking firms in our network offering head and shaft connector fitting systems.
My mantra of recommending that golfers test, test, test, is based on 20 years of testing well over 20,000 golfers. Utilizing a system of interchangeable head and shaft options, the feedback of the golfer, live conditions, a doppler radar system, and my fitting expertise, I have learned that the most important element in the fitting process is the golfer’s interaction with the test clubs.
If a golfer is able to test, in a live setting, off turf, with a variety of head and shaft options, using a methodology of evaluating the success of a given combination based on achieving a performance that is natural, efficient, and powerful, without the need to adjust or modify their body, swing , or game, then the golfer will find their best equipment.
The difficult part is that there remains a huge amount of obstacles in your path. All of us major companies still derive the majority of our sales from “off the rack” purchases, and thus much of our energy is devoted to this side of the business. The media, marketing efforts, and almost every retail sales portal, also continues to support this channel with most of their energy.
Finally, most every golfer is not aware of how to properly test and evaluate clubs. There needs to be a shift in how a golfer thinks about and selects equipment. Currently, golfers think in terms of distance, forgiveness, feel and trajectory that a given golf club produces. However, it is much more than that. Golfers should look to the following 3 point methodology- “What combination of head, shaft, and installation specification allows a golfer to (1) swing with the most power, control and consistency, (2) achieve the most efficient flight, and (3) without the need to adjust his body, swing or game.
For your current search, I would give up the idea of a traditional demo day if you are looking for the complete answer, take my equipment evaluation methodology to heart, and also, give up the idea of hoping that the NS 105T or NS 1100 are going to be offered in a side by side analysis. These shafts are great models, and may or may not be for you, but they are proprietary to Titleist and Callaway, and will only be available in Titleist and Callaway heads, and the only option to pursue in your original note is to find a facility that is a Callaway, Titleist and Nippon Shaft Center, that offers interchangeable combinations- which is quite remote.
Thus, my recommendation is to test the clubs you are considering using the above testing methodology, even if not side by side. If you wish to go beyond these three shaft models, contact one of our Authorized Installation Centers at www.shaftology.com and first inquire if they offer the type of fitting services that you seek. Depending on how much testing detail you desire, you may need to decide on spending time and money to travel to your best location.
One last option is to visit us in Chicago and take advantage of our fitting services that I have described above.Â
Thanks ofr listening to my long note. Best regards, Mark
Posted in Shaft Fitting, Shaft Availability, Frequently Asked, MUST READ!, Golfer Interaction, Ultimate Fitting Destination |
Tuesday, July 20th, 2010
QUESTION: Hi Gang…
Okay… I have played this game for many years..high school and
college.. and tried to qualify for the senior U S Open at 52.. I am 54 now and want to get serious again. Oddly, I have never been fitted for clubs.. I know that there are so many ways now to increase distance and control.Â
I hear you guys make the best lighter shafts … I would think lighter may mean more distance hopefully without losing control. I am exploring and would love your input ..Â
I am about your average size golfer… 5′11′ and 196 lbs.. I am a 4 handicap.. my swing speed is around 100 to maybe 105.. I hit a 7 iron 145 to 158. I use Mizuno MP33 blades. (tried the so-called game inprovement clubs-can’t look at um) Â
Where can I go from this point, as far as technology, to increase distance and take advantage of all that is available…?  If I
simply changed to one of your better lighter shafts in my irons, what could I expect from this ? Is this a good starting point? Â
I wish I knew more about all this tech stuff and really do not have much of a clue about how to go about finding the best situation possible.
The pros have so much of an advantage on most of us.. It is just not a guessing game for them because they have the best possible fit clubs and ball for their individual games.. I want that … HELP!
Thanks, Cecil
ANSWER: Hi Cecil,
Like most every golfer, especially among golfers our age, you grew up finding some equipment that worked reasonably well, and then LEARNED to ADJUST to the rest. This was OK when we were younger, but if we want to play our best, the time has come to leave behind compensations, and choose power and efficiency.
The starting point is a combination of both, the new technology options, but also discovering how to fit our equipment to our bodies and swings.
This means the following- “The best equipment is that which allows us to swing in the most powerful, natural and efficient manner, with the most powerful, natural, efficient flight, without the need for compensation or adjustment in our swing, body or game.”
Are you with me so far?
Your equipment salvation may include one of our premium lightweight shaft models, but it doesn’t start there. It begins with finding a clubfitter or facility that offers a variety of test combinations that, via testing and comparison, will lead your body to finding the best heads, shafts and specifications for your body, swing and game.
You would be wise to consider going to www.shaftology.com and click on our CENTER LOCATOR, and contact several of our Centers, inquiring about the fitting services that they offer.
This is not an easy task to accomplish. Most golfers, and clubmakers, do not understand exactly how things should work, and thus our fitting choices/availabilities are quite mixed up. However, if you pursue live testing, and demand comparative choices, you will find the hottest and most consistent performing equipment.
Please stay in touch with your progress. Regards, MarkÂ
Posted in Frequently Asked, Ultimate Fitting Destination, General Fitting Questions |
Tuesday, June 22nd, 2010
QUESRION: Hi,
My question is about my ball flight. My clubhead speed is about 110-116. My
question is- that without seeing my swing and everything that goes with it, I wanted to know what a good ball flight should be? I talked to a local PGA Pro and they said you don’t want a ballooning flight, and you don’t want a low flight. Thankfully, I don’t have that ball flight, but mine is very high, but not ballooning. I believe that I am not getting the distance because my ball flight is all carry and no roll. Would you recommend going to a stiffer shaft? My current driver loft is 9 degrees and stiff shaft. Thank You, EB
ANSWER: Hello again,
If you fixate on shaft flex and your swing speed, you will miss the relevant parts, and not make the changes needed to achieve your optimal flight.
I completely understand that you are asking which shaft flex will help you find your optimum trajectory, based on your swing speed. However, after many thousands of fitting assessments, I can tell you that trajectory is not simply optimized by finding your best shaft flex.
If you want to achieve the most efficient driver trajectory, you must consider the shaft model geometry, shaft flex, shaft weight, head model geometry, head loft, head weight, club length, and golf ball, but most importantly, your delivery of the driver into the ball at impact.
The major reason why you have all carry and no roll with your driver shots is your steep angle of delivery with your driver at impact. All carry and no roll means that you actually have an inefficient driver ball flight, with a low/flat launch angle, and a high/distance robbing spin, which is the aerodynamic portion of your flight that creates your high trajectory.
If you adjust your shaft flex, your ball flight may improve, but this typically will only gain you a few percentage points of improvement. If you investigate the relationship between your clubhead specifications, clubhead delivery(angle of attack), shaft specifications, and golf ball specifications, and find a more optimum path, you will radically change your ball flight to a more efficient one, and achieve better control in the wind, and greater distance on every driver swing.
Finding your best flight means achieving consistent contact, with a high launch, and a flat, boring type trajectory, which is the inverse of your existing flight pattern.
To embark on this journey requires that you go back and read what I recommended in my earlier post. Working with a skilled fitter, who encounters this flight inefficiency on a regular basis, and with a complete array of test equipment, to help identify the optimal characteristics, will prove to be the least expensive and the most effective format to learn which combination of specifications that will optimize your ball flight.
Below is a link to a post that says the same thing in a slightly different manner.
Optimize Distance via a Professional Assessment
Best regards, Mark
Posted in Shaft Fitting, Frequently Asked, Golfer Interaction, General Fitting Questions |
Monday, June 21st, 2010
QUESTION: Hi,
I have a question on shaft flex based on my swing speed. It’s around 112-116, but I can go faster If needed. My question is- without seeing my swing and all
that, would you recommend going to an x flex?
The reason I’m asking this is with my current driver the trajectory is high and
it’s a 9 degree stiff flex. Thank you, EB
ANSWER: Hi EB,
Your swing speed number will not give you a complete assessment of your shaft needs, head needs, and loft needs. It is a tiny part of the whole story of your game.
Yes, you have a great amount of speed, which typically indicates the possibility of a stiffer flex and a heavier shaft. However, the true method of shaft determination is to test, compare and evaluate shaft models and flexes in a live setting.
At the very least, find a facility that offers some shaft demos where you can compare a Stiff, and an Extra-Stiff flex. It is a waste of your time and energy to rely on just a math formula.
If 100 golfers with your swing speed, connected with a quality fitter, with an array of test shafts, and a functional testing methodology, and then hit a variety of test models- the evaluation would lead to an optimum shaft fit in 90 to 95+ percent of the golfers.
If the same 100 golfers instead based their shaft selection solely on their swing speed number, the number of golfers that would find the optimum shaft, would be in the 5 to 10 percent range.
My best recommendation is to find a quality clubfitter, that offers an array of head and shaft combinations, and learn about which flex performs best, which shaft weight is best for your body, if you are delivering the head to the ball in the most efficient manner, the best length, the best loft, the best head style, and the overall best combination of all of these factors.
One place to start is at www.shaftology.com, by looking up some of our Authorized Installation Centers and inquiring as to the fitting services offered.
Regards, Mark Â
Posted in Shaft Fitting, Frequently Asked, Golfer Interaction, Ultimate Fitting Destination, General Fitting Questions |
Wednesday, April 21st, 2010
QUESTION: Hi,
What is the background behind the uniflex shaft? Is it steel or graphite and is
it comparable to a regular, stiff or x stiff shaft? I saw an ad for Callaway X-
20 irons that had the uniflex shaft. MC
AMSWER: Hi MC,
The term- “uniflex” has been used to communicate a flex rating that is generally between a Regular and a Stiff shaft flex.
Regards, Mark
Posted in Frequently Asked, General Fitting Questions |
Wednesday, April 7th, 2010
QUESTION: Hi Mark,I just wrote to you about the NS PRO 950WF several days ago. I got fitted and
found out that the shafts were way too light, and that it promoted a very
jerky tempo. I was recommended to play the Super Peening Blue shafts in R flex.
Having seen the specs I was a bit initimidated and decided to softstep the R
flex. They feel excellent and I have a smoother tempo and have gained 1 club or
so, maybe more. Considering it is butt kick, I still have a relatively high ball
flight but definitely with less spin. I am wondering if the flex is right for me?Â
I definitely like the feel, not too harsh, yet not too soft. I can have a go and
still keep my dispersion tight. I am basing my flex notion on the height of my
trajectory.
Anyway long story short, I just jumped from the 950 to Super Peening Blue. SinceÂ
I have an extra set of heads, decided to tinker, a friend of mine is selling me a
new set of the red protos in S flex. I have heard of this and know they are
stout. Also there are many variations, but I would be all over this if they were
the 120 gram versions. Unfortunately I do not know what they are, except that the
code is SI-2F15PRO2.
Could you tel me about this particular model? Cost is not a factor as I am
trading it for another piece of gear. I have read your reply to another member
about the red protos in Ebay. Thanks I appreciate all your help and am learning
a lot from Shaftology. C
Â
ANSWER: Hi C,
Thanks for taking the time to write.
I am glad you are having success with your Blue set.
To answer your “flex” question- flex should never be based on a mathematical formula, or solely on trajectory, but on how it feels and performs for you.
A shaft flex is ideal if it-
-feels good to you
-you are able to swing, without the need for adjustment or compensation in your swing
-you are generally able to control your ball flight
-you have a consistent direction in your shots
-you consistently find the center of the face
-you achieve optimal distance.
Regarding the 2F15 model- this is similar to our 1150GH model. You can find our specs at www.nipponshaft.com.
If you like the NS PRO Superpeening Blue model, most likely you will not perform as well with the 2F15 model, due to the different weight and shaft geometry.
Regards, Mark
Posted in Frequently Asked, NS PRO Models |
Thursday, March 11th, 2010
QUESTION: Hi,
I would just like to now the speedratings of the Nippon NS Pro 105T
that come with the Titleist AP1 710 irons? Regards, Mark
ANSWER: Hi Mark,
I thinl I am going to disappoint you. There are no speed ratings
for Nippon Shaft models. Actually, there are no speed ratings for
any shaft models.
Â
Many speed ratings are quoted in brochures and web-sites, but the
true scoop is that they are quite meaningless.
Â
Shaft selection should be chosen based on the following-
1)Choose shaft weight based on which weight class allows your
body to swing fast enough to gain maximum speed, but also is
heavy enough to engage your body in balance and control.
2) Choose the shaft flex that allows your body to swing in
harmony and rhythm and the ability to square the face at
impact, without the need to alter or modify your swing.
This typically means to choose the shaft flex that you have
had success with in the past.
3) Choose the geometry that gives you a good trajectory,
without the need to alter your swing or posture.
Â
Stay away from mathematical shaft concepts- they will
lead you only to a random guess.Â
Choose instead performance concepts- this is how the most
serious players select their shafts. Regards, Mark
Â
Posted in Frequently Asked, Golfer Interaction, Crazy Ideas, General Fitting Questions |
Wednesday, November 25th, 2009
QUESTION: Hi,
I will like to know the difference of these shafts-Â
NS PRO 105T ANDÂ KBS TOUR
I am an 8 handicap. Thanks, GB
Â
ANSWER: Hi GB,
It is not proper for Nippon Shaft to compare our colleagues shaft models. This is like asking the Microsoft Company to compare their products with Apple.
However, the NS 105T is a shaft model that we manufacture for the Titleist Company, and here is a Titleist link that offers a Titleist description for both your shaft models in question. You will need to scroll down the list to find your shafts.
http://www.titleist.com/golfclubs/shafts_grips/shafts/default.asp?Filter=5
My best recommendation is to contact one or two of our Authorized Installation Centers, as they work with all of the premium shaft models in our golf universe and are highly skilled at comparing and describing shaft models.
Of course, the best and most definitive resource, is always your personal trial and feedback. The ultimate selection process is always best determined by your body, swing, feel and flight, which is miles better than any shaft description, fitting guide, or fitter’s input. Regards, MarkÂ
Posted in Frequently Asked |
|
|